The Captain was sober, the First Mate was drunk. Was that true? Was that fair?

, , ,

I’ve been a qualified accountant for a fair few years now.

sailorI had the pleasure of bumping into my first auditing lecturer last week. It was at a business mixer event and even though it was a long time since we last saw each other he really hadn’t changed that much.

We got talking and I reminded him of something that he told me that I’ve remembered ever since and to me is a great way of explaining what is meant by “True and Fair”. Those of you that have studied financial reporting papers will be aware of the importance of “True and Fair” in connection with financial statements.

In summary, financial statements should provide what is generally understood as a true and fair view of the reporting entity’s financial position, performance and changes in financial position.

I always remember my lecturer telling me the story of the ship’s captain that was having a problem with his first mate who was always drunk. In the end the captain wrote an official entry in the captains log saying “Today, the first mate was drunk.”

The first mate was upset about this and the next time he took charge of the ship when the captain was asleep, he wrote in the log that “Today, the captain was sober”. This of course implied that on other days the captain wasn’t sober as he was drunk.

Now, the statement “today, the captain was sober” was clearly true but I’ll leave it up to you to decide whether or not it was fair!

There's nothing fishy about this...

It’s an unfortunate fact of life that some suppliers at the beginning of a supply chain often do most of the work but tend to[..]

Would you have ridden this wave differently?

I've got a couple of friends who are keen surfers. If you speak to them they will tell you that successful surfing is all down[..]

Is it ok to fall asleep in the office?

Have you ever felt the need to close your eyes for a few seconds at work? Maybe even for a few minutes? In fact, have[..]
Who are you sat next to?
If you’re in the office at the moment take a look at the person next to you. Would you say that he or she is[..]
Happy New Desk
Well it’s that time of year again when a lot of people set themselves a New Year Resolution. On average, approximately a third of people[..]
When is an ice cream not an ice cream?
It sounds like the start of a riddle but there’s an important underlying message. Namely, organisations should be monitoring the environment they are operating in[..]
(Un) Happy Christmas Mr Orangutan
Advertising can have a dramatic impact on what people buy and in countries which celebrate Christmas, one of the busiest buying seasons is upon us.[..]