fb

ACCA SPRING SALE 25% OFF

What’s the link between George Bush and the ACCA exams next month?

What’s the link between George Bush and the ACCA exams next month?

George W Bush is a controversial figure.  Two years after leaving office, his policies during his presidency of the United States still stir controversy, both within the USA and around the world.

He has just published his autobiography.  Perhaps surprisingly, he appears to be rather frank in his admission that he personally authorised the use of “water boarding” techniques, in which the subject believes themselves to be drowning.

Although no permanent physical damage occurs in this process, it’s designed to be traumatic. The current US president, Barak Obama has banned its use.

The justification given by the former president for authorising the use of torture was that he believed that the information extracted from the subjects of this process saved lives elsewhere.

We’re not commenting on whether we agree with this or not as an ethical standpoint.

For people taking an ethics exam, such as ACCA paper P1, this could be an interesting example of ethical stances and especially the difference between deontological and teleological (consequentialist ethics).

President Bush’s viewpoint is an example of utilitarian teleological ethics.

In teleological ethics, the rightness or wrongness of the action is assessed by investigating its consequences.  Utilitarianism looks at the greatest benefit to the greatest number of people.  So if great, but non-lethal, suffering of one person saves the life of another, it’s justifiable, even if the act itself may be repugnant to some people.

Compare that with deontological ethics and particularly the three maxims of Emmanuel Kant.

In deontological ethics, water boarding is probably never justifiable.

Deontology looks at the rightness or wrongness of the action itself, regardless of its consequences.  It would be possible to express a duty (“imperative”) if it passes the three maxims of Kant:

Consistency: Would it be possible for everybody to follow the rule of “no waterboarding”?  The answer here seems to be yes.

Respect for human dignity: Does the rule respect the dignity of others.  A no torture rule easily passes this test.

Universality: Would it be possible for somebody to understand that breaking the rule would bring the disapproval of society as a whole?  Again, the answer here is yes.  If torture were universally accepted as wrong, it would be possible for a violator of that rule to anticipate society’s disapproval.

There are no conclusions to this article.  It’s just pointing out an example of the two different ethical approaches and how we are each prone to prefer one over the other in different circumstances.

It could be a good example for people taking the P1 exam to use if asked to explain the differences in the deontological and teleological approaches to ethics.

Share this entry

Recent articles

View All Articles
Nothing to whine about…
Apr 22, 2025
Title
Nothing to whine about…
Excerpt

The wine industry, steeped in centuries of tradition, is experiencing a shake-up that’s sparking debate among enthusiasts and […]

PwC exits 9 African countries
Apr 18, 2025
Title
PwC exits 9 African countries
Excerpt

PwC, one of the Big Four accounting firms, recently announced the closure of its operations in nine Sub-Saharan […]

Using AI to reward staff
Apr 12, 2025
Title
Using AI to reward staff
Excerpt

In a bold move that combines innovation with employee incentives, UK-based law firm Shoosmiths has become the first […]

Barking up the right tree?
Apr 07, 2025
Title
Barking up the right tree?
Excerpt

In a world where businesses are constantly seeking that elusive “wow” factor to stand out, a historic Parisian […]

10 reasons CFOs are leaving…
Apr 02, 2025
Title
10 reasons CFOs are leaving…
Excerpt

Last year, chief financial officers (CFOs) left their roles at the fastest rate in six years, according to […]

Women at the top: EY becomes first Big 4 firm with dual female leaders
Apr 01, 2025
Title
Women at the top: EY becomes first Big 4 firm with dual female leaders
Excerpt

EY has just made history – Alison Duncan will take over as UK Chair of EY, joining forces […]

When Audits Fail: PwC, Wyelands Bank, and the £2.9M Mistake
Mar 26, 2025
Title
When Audits Fail: PwC, Wyelands Bank, and the £2.9M Mistake
Excerpt

What happens when auditors fail to properly understand the business they’re auditing? That’s the question at the heart […]

Volkswagen sells more sausages than cars
Mar 18, 2025
Title
Volkswagen sells more sausages than cars
Excerpt

No, we’ve not made an early April Fools Joke. It’s true. Volkswagen do sell more sausages than cars. […]