fb

What type of fine do you get for cheating?

What type of fine do you get for cheating?

McLaren are one of the top Formula One motor racing teams. They are not only experts at ensuring cars are driven fast around racing circuits but they are also experts at ensuring that £34m fines are tax deductible…

Back in 2007 McLaren were fined £34 million pounds because it “had possessed and in some way used proprietary information belonging to Ferrari, and had thereby breached the rules of the FIA’s International Sporting Code to which McLaren was contractually bound”.

Or to put it another way, they had cheated by photocopying an 800 page technical document belonging to Ferrari that detailed the designs of the 2007 Ferrari cars.

Formula One’s governing body, the Federation Internationale de L’Automobile (FIA), weren’t happy about McLaren taking this approach and ordered McLaren to pay a £34m fine which they duly did.

The interesting thing though is that in their UK company tax return McLaren claimed a tax deduction for the fine.

In the UK as well as most countries around the world, fines are not tax deductible. This means that the expense does not reduce the level of profits on which tax is calculated.

McLaren argued though that this particular fine was tax deductible (i.e. the expense could be used to reduce the level of profits on which tax was applied). They said that it wasn’t a statutory fine for breaking the law (which would be non tax deductible) but instead was a fine imposed by their governing body and as such was a genuine business expense incurred in their trade which should be tax deductible.

The UK tax authorities understandably didn’t agree with this viewpoint and the argument went to an independent tax tribunal who surprisingly agreed with McLaren and said that the fine was tax deductible.

A surprising decision and there’s no truth in the rumour that the head of the independent tax tribunal is currently driving around in a McLaren…

Share this entry

Recent articles

View All Articles
Big 4 under the spotlight…
May 22, 2024
Title
Big 4 under the spotlight…
Excerpt

Recent findings have shown that Britain’s audit firms did not raise alarms for three-quarters of the major companies […]

Better than the professionals?
May 13, 2024
Title
Better than the professionals?
Excerpt

The landscape of investing is evolving, with the rise of retail, or “do-it-yourself” (DIY) investors who are achieving […]

Don’t get angry over anger management
May 07, 2024
Title
Don’t get angry over anger management
Excerpt

Have you ever been angry at work? If you have then you are not alone. The latest Global […]

Cows or dogs in your portfolio?
May 01, 2024
Title
Cows or dogs in your portfolio?
Excerpt

As well as being included in ACCA, CIMA and CMA (USA) exam questions over the years, the Boston […]

KPMG unlocks previously locked up talent.
Apr 30, 2024
Title
KPMG unlocks previously locked up talent.
Excerpt

KPMG, one of the Big Four accounting firms, has recently announced its commitment to expanding its hiring of […]

Taxing times…
Apr 24, 2024
Title
Taxing times…
Excerpt

Understanding the various forms of taxation is essential for business students worldwide. Taxes serve not only as a […]

From Coins to Codes: A Budgeting Timeline
Apr 22, 2024
Title
From Coins to Codes: A Budgeting Timeline
Excerpt

The concept of budgeting, a cornerstone in both personal finance and corporate management, has a rich history that […]

Italian but not Italian…
Apr 17, 2024
Title
Italian but not Italian…
Excerpt

In the complex landscape of global business, the names of products and brands hold significant power. They convey […]