fb

Who can really be trusted to keep a secret? Accountants or lawyers?

When you speak with your lawyer, you can say almost anything and be confident in the knowledge that the lawyer will be able to preserve the confidentiality of your discussion.

Most people probably assume the same thing when having discussions with their accountant, especially in the context of discussing tax planning opportunities with a tax advisor.

Unfortunately, English readers should pay careful attention to the decision in a recent case, R (on the application of Prudential PLC) v HMRC, EWCA Civ 1094 if you would like the full legal citation.

This Court of Appeal decision stated that client privilege only extends between a lawyer and a client.  This means that any discussion between a client and an accountant cannot be guaranteed to be confidential.

This is an English legal case, which is binding in England and Wales only, but the judgment is based on common law, so is likely to be highly influential in jurisdictions based on the English system globally.

As the accountancy and legal professions increasingly compete, especially in the area of tax advice, this gives a significant advantage to the legal profession over the accountancy profession.

Who would you rather seek advice from: a lawyer who you are confident cannot be compelled to reveal the content of your discussion, or an expert accountant who is unable to promise confidentiality?

If you talk to a lawyer about this then they may well say they were pleased that they had this advantage over accountants.

Note of course though that if they felt like it they wouldn’t have to disclose what was said in your conversation…

Share this entry

Recent articles

View All Articles
Insider Trading: A Cautionary Tale from the Oil Industry
Feb 29, 2024
Title
Insider Trading: A Cautionary Tale from the Oil Industry
Excerpt

In the complex world of finance, insider trading remains one of the most controversial and closely watched issues. […]

Lessons from Kraft Heinz’s Sales Decline
Feb 20, 2024
Title
Lessons from Kraft Heinz’s Sales Decline
Excerpt

In the fast-paced world of business, staying ahead of market trends and consumer preferences is paramount. The recent […]

The strategic rationale behind Uber’s share buyback…
Feb 15, 2024
Title
The strategic rationale behind Uber’s share buyback…
Excerpt

In the realm of corporate finance, decisions regarding share buybacks often spark curiosity and sometimes confusion among investors […]

Adapting to the Digital Age: Lessons from Sky TV
Feb 09, 2024
Title
Adapting to the Digital Age: Lessons from Sky TV
Excerpt

In the ever-evolving landscape of the entertainment industry, adaptability is key to survival. Recently, Sky TV, a prominent […]

EY’s Hybrid Work Insights
Jan 29, 2024
Title
EY’s Hybrid Work Insights
Excerpt

The world of business has seen a significant transformation in recent years, with the COVID-19 pandemic acting as […]

From blades to balance sheets…
Jan 26, 2024
Title
From blades to balance sheets…
Excerpt

Consumer behavior is constantly evolving, and businesses must adapt to these changes to stay relevant and profitable. One […]

Keep it in the family?
Jan 26, 2024
Title
Keep it in the family?
Excerpt

In the world of business, family companies often occupy a unique and intriguing position. They combine the dynamics […]

Benchmarking, football VAR and pilots…
Jan 23, 2024
Title
Benchmarking, football VAR and pilots…
Excerpt

In the ever-evolving world of business, staying ahead of the competition is essential. Companies constantly seek ways to […]