fb

ACCA SUMMER SALE 20% OFF

Historical costs deserve more friends.

Historical costs deserve more friends.

Historical cost accounting lies at the core of accountancy.  It’s derived from the simplicity of debits and credits and is therefore where we all start in our studies and practice of our profession.

The idea is simple; I pay some cash and that gives me either an expense or an asset.  With the exception of freehold land, all assets are simply future expenses, as all assets except freehold land wear out.  This means that sooner or later, they’ll all pass through profit and loss as an expense.

There are some well-known problems with historical costs.  Most notably, they begin to fall apart in terms of reliability during a period of inflation.  Depreciating the cost of a factory bought 20 years ago gives a lower depreciation charge than a factory bought last year.  If inventory is held for a long time before sale, historical cost accounting matches today’s revenue with yesterday’s costs; thus overstating profit.  All these things damage the relevance and reliability of financial statements and reliability is one of the core characteristics of what makes financial information useful, according to the IASB Framework.

Relevance and reliability aside, let’s face it; historical cost accounting is just not very sexy.  Dreary and reliable and borne of something as mundane as debits and credits, it’s hard to get excited about a balance sheet (SOFP) that shows its assets just as what was paid for them rather than what they’re worth.  So, enter revaluations and fair values.  Modifying historical cost accounting for revaluations means assets are shown at a more up-to-date, relevant (and frankly higher) value.  But it comes with a downside – your depreciation charges will now be higher, thus reducing profit.  Your eventual profit on sale will be lower, as the carrying value used to calculate profit will be higher.  Increasingly, you might come to have problems with investors not trusting the revalued amounts.  So perhaps we’ve substituted one form of plodding unreliability for a higher octane form of volatile unreliability?

This is a debate that has two valid sides to the argument.  But recent stock market falls and pervasive impairment losses mean that we suspect that the familiar world of pure historical cost accounting might start to look more attractive again.  It might be a bit dull, but at least people know what it means.

Share this entry

Recent articles

View All Articles
It’s all hands on deck moving from Big 4 to 4 people…
Jun 17, 2025
Title
It’s all hands on deck moving from Big 4 to 4 people…
Excerpt

When multinational companies switch auditors, it’s usually a move that signals routine rotation, cost management, or strategic realignment. […]

From whisky to wickets…
Jun 16, 2025
Title
From whisky to wickets…
Excerpt

Diageo, the global drinks giant behind brands like Guinness, Smirnoff and Johnnie Walker, is reportedly considering a sale […]

“Just Build It” – the Nike LEGO collaboration
Jun 12, 2025
Title
“Just Build It” – the Nike LEGO collaboration
Excerpt

Nike and LEGO are teaming up to launch co-branded products and experiences aimed at inspiring kids through active […]

Laziness and intelligence.
Jun 12, 2025
Title
Laziness and intelligence.
Excerpt

Whilst a lot of you won’t admit to being lazy (and I’m sure most of you aren’t in […]

The road to electric cars is full of potholes…
May 28, 2025
Title
The road to electric cars is full of potholes…
Excerpt

The electric vehicle (EV) market has seen tremendous growth in recent years, with major car manufacturers and startups […]

Is the stage set for airline pricing at the theatre?
May 26, 2025
Title
Is the stage set for airline pricing at the theatre?
Excerpt

Imagine paying £300 for a theatre ticket, only to find there’s more to pay if you want to […]

WeightWatchers files for bankruptcy as drugs take over…
May 12, 2025
Title
WeightWatchers files for bankruptcy as drugs take over…
Excerpt

Weight-loss drugs like Ozempic and Wegovy have revolutionised the weight management market, leaving companies which were once dominant […]

A whole new world: Disney’s Middle East move
May 08, 2025
Title
A whole new world: Disney’s Middle East move
Excerpt

The Walt Disney Company has announced its first-ever theme park in the Middle East, set to be built […]