The largest single property deal in UK history, both in form and…in substance

,

Sale and leaseback of a very noticeable building by a very noticeable bank! Is this a sign of a bank needing cash flow to shore up its solvency? Or just a good opportunity at a good moment in time? And how do we tell the shareholders about it?

In 2007, HSBC sold and leased back its iconic headquarters in London, the 1.1 million square foot, 210 metre high, tower at 8 Canada Square, Canary Wharf.

Imagine yourself in a top floor office as a proud HSBC accountant about to book this transaction in the bank’s IFRS statements.

The buyer-lessor was a wholly-owned subsidiary of Metrovacesa, S.A. one of Europe’s highest profile property companies. Under the terms of the agreement, HSBC sold the tower for £1.09  billion and leased it back for 20 years (with an extension option for a further 5 years) against an annual rent of £43.5 million. HSBC had moved in 2002, having incurred some £500 million in tower’s construction costs.

So, how would you account for it?

First, you need to determine the nature of the lease: finance or operating? Based on available information, the lease has fair chances to be operating, as (a) the term is 20(+5) years, with the building (the useful life of which may exceed 40 years) being only 5 years old on lease inception, and (b) the present value of the agreed annual rents probably falls significantly below the upfront selling value.

If that would be the case (operating lease-back), you would (a) take the building out of HSBC’ balance-sheet at its carrying amount, (b) recognise upfront the profit made on disposal, and (c) subsequently take the incurred rental costs to operating expenses, on an accruals basis.

Fairly straightforward, isn’t it ?

Is this worth smiling for?
Are you happy when you spend money? I guess the answer depends on what you’re spending the money on but over in China, KFC have[..]
An awkward mistake.
Have you ever sent an email to the wrong person by mistake? What about posting something on social media which, with hindsight you’d wished you[..]
OMG - will these hit the shelves?
Procter & Gamble, or P&G as it’s commonly known, is one of the world’s largest companies and has an incredible portfolio of products including Gillette,[..]
Grant Thornton fined £4million.
Grant Thornton, the mid-tier accounting firm has been fined £4m and reprimanded by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC). So, what did they do wrong? It[..]
Something to crow about...
At the time of writing the Puy du Fou historical theme park in France has got over 12,000 TripAdvisor reviews and a 5 star rating.[..]